How to respond to a rental inquiry
Reply fast, greet the renter by first name, confirm which apartment they asked about, ask a few short questions, and offer a next step. Below is the reply every AgentResponder account starts with, why each line is there, a shorter text version, and what to send when things are different.
Updated · The templates shown are the ones every new AgentResponder account starts with.
Anatomy of a first reply
What should a reply to a rental inquiry include?
Six parts, and none of them takes more than a sentence or two.
- 01
Their first name
“Hello Sarah” reads like a person wrote it. “Dear applicant” reads like a form.
- 02
Who you are and the exact apartment
Renters ask about several apartments at once. Naming the address, unit included, tells them which one you mean.
- 03
A quick thank-you
One line is enough. It sets a friendly tone before the questions.
- 04
A few short questions
Ask only what you need before a showing. Short questions get answered. A long form gets put off until later, and later often never comes.
- 05
A next step
Ask when they can see it. A question about timing moves the conversation toward a showing.
- 06
Short, plain paragraphs
Most renters read your reply on a phone. Keep each paragraph to a line or two and skip attachments.
The template
A rental inquiry reply template you can copy
This is the AgentResponder Template, the first reply every new account starts with. The blue parts are filled in for each renter: their first name (or “there” when the inquiry has no name) and the address they asked about.
Replace the {{Fill in YOUR name here ONCE and save it}} line with your own name before you use it. After that it's your reply, so change anything you like.
AgentResponder Template
First reply, email and text
Hello [First Name],
This is {{Fill in YOUR name here ONCE and save it}}, the listing agent for the apartment you inquired about at [Listing Address]. Thanks for reaching out!
To get you scheduled for a tour quickly, a few quick questions:
What is your preferred move-in date?
What is your total household income and credit score(s)?
And when are you available to tour?
Last thing: do you have any pets, and will anyone be co-signing or guaranteeing the lease with you?
The questions
Why ask these questions in the first reply?
“What is your preferred move-in date?”
Tells you right away whether their timing works with when the apartment is free.
“What is your total household income and credit score(s)?”
Most NYC landlords screen on income and credit, and many look for a yearly income of about 40 times the monthly rent. For a renter with a housing voucher or other rental help, that rule only applies to the part of the rent they pay. Asking up front saves you both a trip if the apartment isn't a fit.
“And when are you available to tour?”
This is the next step. A renter who answers it is ready to see the place.
“Do you have any pets?”
Buildings have their own pet rules, so it helps to know before the showing. Service animals and emotional support animals aren't pets, and a renter with a disability can ask for an exception to a no-pets rule, so never turn someone away over one.
“Will anyone be co-signing or guaranteeing the lease with you?”
If their income or credit falls short, a guarantor or co-signer can still make the application work, so it's worth knowing early.
Whatever you ask, ask every renter the same questions. More on that in what to leave out.
The text version
How should the text be different from the email?
Shorter. A text gets read in a glance, so keep the greeting, the address and one or two questions, and let the email carry the rest.
AgentResponder sends a text only when the inquiry includes a phone number and you've connected a texting app. New accounts start with the same wording for the email and the text, so shorten the text once and save it. If a listing's text box is left blank, the text uses the email's wording.
Example text
Variations
Four situations that need a different reply
They'd like to see a video first
Add a Video link to the listing and it goes at the end of the reply under its own label, with a short note if you write one. A Listing link is added the same way, without a note. Each can be set for the email, the text or both.
Video: Identical unit, 2R https://…
This one may not be the right fit
Put [Similar Apartments] on its own line and the reply also offers up to 3 of your other active listings that fit, by size, rent and neighborhood. When none fit, the line is left out.
If this one isn't the right fit, I also have: - a 2 bedroom in Williamsburg for $3,300/month at 12 Oak Ave #2 - a 2 bedroom in Williamsburg for $3,150/month at 88 Bedford Ave #4F
You're away for a few days
With Out of Office on, renters get your away message instead of your usual reply, by email and text, until your return date. It has no listing links, and follow-ups wait until you're back. Keep it short and say when you'll answer.
Hi [First Name], thanks for asking about [Listing Address]. I'm away until Monday and will answer as soon as I'm back.
Another agent asks on StreetEasy
An agent asking for a client needs different questions. This is the AgentResponder Agent Template. It can answer StreetEasy agent inquiries for you on listings where you turn that on (it's off by default).
Hi [First Name], thanks for reaching out about [Listing Address]! Please let me know the following about your client:
- Total Household Income:
- Credit Score(s):
- Move-In Date:
- Number of Applicants:
- Will they be using a Guarantor(s):
And when are they available to tour?
What to leave out
What not to put in a first reply
- Long paragraphs. A wall of text on a phone gets skimmed or saved for later.
- Attachments and application forms. Send those after the showing, when the renter wants the apartment.
- Requests for a Social Security number or bank details. Renters shouldn't send those to someone they just met over email, and you don't need them yet.
- Questions about criminal history or past evictions. In New York City, the Fair Chance for Housing law bars asking about criminal history before a conditional offer, and New York law bars turning a renter down over past housing court cases.
- Questions you don't ask every renter. If a question only comes up for some people, leave it out for everyone.
Fair housing, in plain words
Ask every renter the same questions, and treat all lawful income the same way. New York law bans discrimination based on a renter's lawful source of income, including housing vouchers, so an income rule applies only to the part of the rent a voucher doesn't cover. If you're unsure about a question, check with your brokerage before you add it to a template.
Where to send it
Should you reply in the inquiry's thread?
Yes, when the thread is only that renter's, so your answer sits right under their question. AgentResponder does this for StreetEasy inquiries and for rentals posted directly on Zillow. Syndicated Zillow contacts are the exception: Zillow puts every renter for that listing in one notification thread, so AgentResponder writes to the renter in a new email instead.
Send it without typing it
Your reply, sent in under 5 minutes.Even when you're at a showing.
Connect your Gmail
Sign in with Google using the Gmail or Google Workspace inbox where your Zillow and StreetEasy inquiries arrive.
Verified by Google for Gmail and Google Calendar access
Passed an independent CASA security assessment
Add your listings
Add each apartment with its reply. The AgentResponder Template above is already in your account, ready to edit.
Turn on automatic replies
New inquiries get your reply in under 5 minutes by default, day or night, from your own Gmail. Setup takes about 5 minutes.
More on how it handles each site: Zillow auto reply and StreetEasy auto reply. For renters who don't answer, see the rental lead follow-up schedule.
Questions agents ask
Rental inquiry reply FAQ
What should I say when I respond to a rental inquiry?
Greet the renter by first name, say who you are and which apartment you're writing about, thank them, ask a few short questions (move-in date, income and credit, when they can tour), and end with a next step. Keep it short enough to read on a phone.
What questions should I ask a renter before a showing?
Their move-in date, total household income and credit score(s), when they're available to tour, whether they have pets, and whether anyone will co-sign or guarantee the lease. Ask every renter the same questions.
Is it OK to ask about income and credit in the first reply?
It's common in New York rentals, because landlords screen on both. Ask every renter the same way and count all lawful income. For a renter with a housing voucher or other rental help, any income rule applies only to the part of the rent they pay, since New York law protects a renter's lawful source of income. Never ask for documents or a Social Security number by email.
What do I reply when the apartment is already rented?
Say it's rented and offer something close: the same size, a similar rent, the same area. If you use AgentResponder, pause the listing the day it rents so new inquiries for it get no automatic reply, and add [Similar Apartments] to your other listings' replies so renters see more than one option from the start.
How do I reply to another agent who asks about my listing on StreetEasy?
Ask what you need to know about their client: total household income, credit score(s), move-in date, number of applicants, whether they'll use a guarantor, and when they're available to tour. That's the AgentResponder Agent Template, which can answer StreetEasy agent inquiries for you on listings where you turn it on.
Should my first reply be an email, a text, or both?
Both, when you can. The email holds the details, and a text is quicker to notice. AgentResponder always sends the email, and sends a text too when the inquiry includes a phone number and you've connected a texting app. Leads from rentals posted directly on Zillow don't include a phone number, so they get the email only.
Write it once.Let it go out for you.
No credit card required · Cancel anytime · For licensed New York real estate agents
Prefer to talk first? Book a 15-minute call
AgentResponder is independent and isn't affiliated with or endorsed by Zillow or StreetEasy.