How to follow up with rental leads who go quiet
Keep it short and close together. Reply in under 5 minutes, follow up about 3 hours later, again the next day, once more two days after that, and then stop. Stop the moment they write back. That's the schedule every AgentResponder account starts with, and you can change any of it.
Updated · The messages shown are the follow-ups every new AgentResponder account starts with.
Why it happens
Why do rental leads stop answering?
Usually it isn't personal. A renter who goes quiet after your first message is often:
- writing to several agents about several apartments at once
- at work, and planning to answer later
- put off by a first reply that asked for too much
- already leaning toward another place
- really after a different unit than the one they clicked
- waiting on a roommate or partner before they commit to a showing
A short, friendly follow-up brings back the ones who meant to answer, and gives the rest an easy way to say no.
The schedule
A follow-up schedule for rental leads
A rental search moves in days, not months, so the whole sequence fits in a few days. Each wait counts from the message before it.
- First replyIn under 5 minutesEmail, plus a text if they left a phone number
- Follow-Up #13 hours after the first replyEmail and text
- Follow-Up #21 day after Follow-Up #1Email and text
- Follow-Up #32 days after Follow-Up #2Email and text
- StopAfter the last step, or the moment they write backNothing more goes out
Texts need a phone number from the renter and a texting app connected to AgentResponder. Three hours gives the renter time to answer on their own, while your apartment is still fresh in their mind.
The messages
What to say in each follow-up
Keep each message short and about the apartment they asked about. The first two just check in. The third widens the search and offers your other units.
Follow-Up #1
3 hours after the first reply
Hi {First_Name}, Following up on your inquiry for [Listing Address]?
Text
Hello {First_Name}, following up on your inquiry for [Listing Address]?
Follow-Up #2
1 day after Follow-Up #1
Hi {First_Name}, wanted to check in one more time about your inquiry for [Listing Address]. Let me know if you're still interested or have any questions - happy to help whenever works for you.
Text
Hi {First_Name}, checking in once more about your inquiry on [Listing Address] - still interested?
Follow-Up #3
2 days after Follow-Up #2
Hi {First_Name}! Are you still looking for an apartment? Would you like to view this apartment or what is your budget, move-in date, and locations you're interested in? I have other units to offer you.
Text
Hi {First_Name}! Are you still looking for an apartment? Would you like to view this apartment or what is your budget, move-in date, and locations you're interested in? I have other units to offer you.
The highlighted parts are filled in for each renter. You can rewrite any of these, and the first-reply template works the same way.
Should you text, email or call?
Use all three. The email always goes out, in the same thread as your first reply, so the renter sees the whole conversation in one place. A text goes out too when they left a phone number and you've connected a texting app, and it's the one they're most likely to see first. The call is yours to make. If a lead hasn't answered by the first follow-up, a quick call is the one thing automation can't do for you. If you call, call every quiet lead, not just some.
When should you stop?
As soon as they answer, even if the answer is no thanks. AgentResponder stops the sequence when the renter writes back by email in your reply's thread. With Quo (OpenPhone), a text back stops it too. With other texting apps only an email reply stops it automatically, so keep an eye on your texts. Three follow-ups over a few days is plenty for a rental lead, and if someone asks you to stop, stop.
Timing
Follow-ups that respect the clock
Follow-Up Hours
Optional hours for follow-ups, so a 3-hour step doesn't land at 2 AM. With them off, follow-ups can go out at any hour.
Blackout dates
No replies or follow-ups go out on the days you block, like holidays.
Out of Office
Follow-ups wait while you're away and pick up again when Out of Office ends.
One sequence per renter
A renter who asked about several of your listings gets one follow-up, not one for each listing.
After the last follow-up
What to do with leads who never answered
They're not gone. Every inquiry AgentResponder answers stays in Recent Replies with the apartment's neighborhood, bedrooms, bathrooms and rent, even after the listing is deleted. When a similar apartment comes up, filter for it (say, last August's 2-bedroom Williamsburg leads), select them and send the new listing with Bulk Contact. Each person gets their own message, once. Having their consent and honoring STOP requests is up to you.
On listings with Follow-Up on, Recent Replies also shows whether the renter wrote back and after which follow-up, so you can see which step is doing the work.
In AgentResponder
Turn on Follow‑Up once.It follows up with new leads on that listing.
Turn it on for a listing
Open a listing and switch on Follow-Up. It starts with the three steps above, as email and text.
Make it yours
Edit the wording or timing, add steps, remove them or change their order.
Choose who gets it
By default, only inquiries that arrive after you turn it on get follow-ups. Tick the box to include earlier ones too.
Follow-Up is included on every plan and in the 30-day free trial. It starts after your first reply, which AgentResponder sends in under 5 minutes by default: see how it handles Zillow rental leads and StreetEasy inquiries.
Questions agents ask
Rental lead follow-up FAQ
How many times should you follow up with a rental lead?
Three times is a good default: about 3 hours after your first reply, a day after that, and two days after the second. Stop as soon as they answer.
How long should you wait before following up on a rental inquiry?
A few hours. AgentResponder's first follow-up goes out 3 hours after the first reply by default, which gives the renter time to answer before you check in again.
Should I text or email a renter who hasn't answered?
Both, if you have their number. AgentResponder sends each follow-up as an email in the same thread as your first reply, and as a text when the renter left a phone number and you've connected a texting app.
What should a follow-up text to a renter say?
One short question about the apartment they asked about, with their name and the address. For example: “Hello Sarah, following up on your inquiry for 245 Grand St #3B?” The last one can widen the search: ask about their budget, move-in date and the areas they like, and offer other units.
When should I stop following up?
As soon as they write back, even to say no thanks, and after the third follow-up if they never do. AgentResponder stops on its own when the renter replies by email, or by text if you use Quo (OpenPhone).
Will follow-ups go out at night or on holidays?
By default, yes. Follow-Up Hours is off until you turn it on, so a follow-up can go out at any hour, holidays included. Turn on Follow-Up Hours to choose when they go out, add blackout dates for holidays, and turn on Out of Office when you're away. Follow-ups wait while Out of Office is on and pick up again after.
Quiet leads, followed up for you.
No credit card required · Cancel anytime · For licensed New York real estate agents
Prefer to talk first? Book a 15-minute call
AgentResponder is independent and isn't affiliated with or endorsed by Zillow or StreetEasy.